Paper books versus ebooks?

Okay.  Let me start off by saying that I have nothing against ebooks.  Nothing at all.  They certainly have their place, and I wouldn't be against publishing a novel or two via the net.  It's just that I prefer the dinosaur variety (hardcopy) when it comes to relaxing reading.  I've been hearing a lot of hype about how eventually the real-hold-'em-in-your-hand books will eventually be passe.  This has to be &%!*#!  At least I hope so. 

What's everybody else's opinion on this?  Does anyone prefer ebooks over paper books?

"Kindness is the language which the deaf can hear and the blind can see."

- Mark Twain

Tags

I love the feel of holding

I love the feel of holding a book in my hands--so, far I have resisted the idea of reading an ebook.

Nancy

I go both ways

I like the "real" books mostly, but for traveling or waiting in lines I love my ebooks. They fit on my Palm and I always have that, which means I always have a book with me.

Bonsal

It depends

It depends where/when I'm reading my books...  If I don't know where I'm going to be sitting and reading, the print books are most convenient.  Reading by the pool or bath, again print books are best because you don't want the laptop falling in water! 

I like reading ebooks though at night, it saves me having to get lots of reading lights turned on.  I just can read right off the screen in my bedroom and when I'm ready to fall asleep, just minimize the screen and shut it off. 

I've seen the light....

Wow, Janet85, that's the best darn defense of ebooks I've seen yet.  I haven't thought about the light issue before.  I keep my husband awake at night sometimes because of a book I just can't put down.  He'd love it if I turned out all the lights and laid quietly with my laptop!  Tips the scales in technology's favor a bit more! Wink Bonsal makes sense about taking the ebooks traveling too.  But so far I've been like Sheadeen - real books have been my picks. 

"Kindness is the language which the deaf can hear and the blind can see."

- Mark Twain

Heheh...  glad you like my

Heheh...  glad you like my reasons.  :p 

 

About travelling...  I just went on a long bus ride to visit someone out of town...  and I brought with me a bunch of ebooks and paperbooks because i wasn't sure where/when I'd have time to read.  AND a great argument for ebooks while travelling... is that if you're travelling and it gets dark, you can always read an ebook!  You can't read paper books without light in a car. 

Anyway... i ended up reading Blaze ebooks on the bus, which I think was probably a good choice.  Would have been a little embarrassing to have the naughty/suggestive Blaze covers open on my lap in the bus.  (My other choices were a Presents ebook, and some Paranormal romance paper books)

I read both...

but I don't have something portable yet for my ebooks so at this point my reason for reading ebooks is because there are some great books out there that aren't in print.  But I do prefer the feel of a paper copy in my hands....

but I like ebooks, too. Which I wouldn't have said a couple of years ago. Actually, a couple of years ago, I didn't even know that there are ebooks. If you want the details of how I came to ebooks, you can read my blog entries from January: ebooks 1 and ebooks 2.

One obvious drawback to ebooks is what happens if the technology changes? Will you be able to "update" your books so that you can read them? Also, what happens if you get someplace without your device's charger and your book "dies" in the middle?

But there are several pros about electronic books (as noted in prior posts and in what I'm about to add). 

Bottom line is, nothing beats a day being curled up with a good book in a good chair and no chores or tasks hanging over your head. But I've read eBooks standing in the dark waiting for my caucus (sp?) to start (we had to wait outside til certain things happen), I've read in bed and not disturbed the dh b/c of the backlight, I've read at the symphony while waiting for the performance to begin . . . I've taken both print and ebooks on vacation and it's really nice and comforting to know that

  1. I shouldn't run out of books while on vaccy and
  2. If I do, I can always get to a computer and buy more.

I have a friend whose sister reads erotica and commutes on public transport and likes that no one knows what she's reading. I have another friend who works in a day care and sometimes has books that she doesn't want others to see even the cover of.

My mom's family lives in the middle of nowhere (really -- you can't imagine it unless you also have family that live an hour from the closest grocery store and who keep gas pumps on their property), so ebooks and downloadable audio would be nice if you're stuck with nothing that you feel like reading between trips to town.

And while I'd rather Harlequin Enterprises reprint some old favorites (in the print format), we're more likely to get them only in electronic format and that's better than nothing (there's actually a thread in the Digital Media Forum where they ask what backlist books we want).

I'll repeat what MasterPuppeteer said a couple of years ago and add on to it: Publishers are in the business of selling stories, no matter what format. And those of us addicted to stories yes have our preferred format but will take a good story in whatever manner we can get it . . .

So let's sum up what we've all said so far:

  • The backlight feature on many devices is nice in bed, in cars, in a big living room when the whole extended family is around (e.g. holidays) etc (you don't disturb others with a need for a certain level of lighting)
  • The ability to have books with you wherever -- vacation, standing in line somewhere -- is a nice convenience (memory cards allow some devices to hold 100-200 full-length books)
  • You can buy ebooks when you can't buy other books as long as you have a computer online (e.g., in middle of the night, at times when you're stuck in the middle of nowhere)
  • Some books are only available electronically
  • So that others can't tell what you're reading (esp. the "red lines")

I know someone who puts her device (not a laptop, a dedicated reader or PDA) in a ziplock bag when she's at the beach, the pool or reading in the tub. I haven't been brave enough to try that yet . . .

Penn

Penn, you make some really

WinkPenn, you make some really good arguments for ebooks and I will have to think about this some more, however for those of you who feel funny about displaying some of your books because of...say the covers, there are some solutions. We go to craft fairs and I found this wonderful leather book cover that hides a multiple of sins.  We used to camp with a group of friends every Memorial Day weekend. One of the guys in the group thought I was doing my daily devotionals whenever he saw me reading my leather covered book. InnocentLOL  When he mentioned this in front of the group of women, we all burst out laughing. Then I had to confess what my 'devotionals' were all about. EmbarassedWink

Nancy

I want my devotional cover

ROTFLMAO about your "devotions" Sheandeen.

I've taken to eBooks for the steamy cover books I don't want others to know I'm reading, but I may have to just get myself a nice leather cover now...

There will always be printed books as long as there are bibliophiles in the world. Laughing

"Life is pain Highness, anyone who tells you otherwise is selling you something." - Dred Pirate Roberts, The Princess Bride
Participating author in Pass the Plot, Summer 2008

I have laughed more about

I have laughed more about that incident over the years--I have also purchased covers for my daughters books and he has made a couple of special sizes for some of the odd book sizes. They last forever.

Nancy

ebooks and me

I admit that I am relatively new to ebooks.  As in, I have read one on my computer and today got a Palm to read them on while on trips with my hubby.  I gave it much thought before the purchase.  Here are some of the things I considered and why I came to the conclusion that I did.

 I dislike some of the corny covers on books and really dislike having nosey people giving me "that look".  You all know the one I am talking about so I am not even gonna describe it.

 I'm so uptight about the condition of my books.  I get upset whenever I travel and my covers get bent/creased.  This usually results in me packing a seperate bag for books (yes, I usually have to take at least four or five with me on a trip) to ensure their safety.  Now that I have my Palm I plan on just dumping everything I want on to a card and packing one paperback book in my purse.  The paperback will be my backup book, just in case I damage the Palm or have battery issues.  LOL  I can NOT be without my books.

There are many books now available only in e form that I want to read.  And I do not want to sit in front of my computer all evening/morning and read.  I've done this once, thus the purchase of the Palm.  Plus, I don't have a laptop and packing the pc isn't are viable option.

The downside to ebooks in my opinion.  I love my books.  I get warm tinglies when I go to a bookstore.  And it's wonderful to search out that perfect book by touch.  I want to stroke the spines and smell the pages.  I take joy in looking at all of my books on my shelves.  And while having them on an SD card will save me tons of space and I will no longer feel guilt for books that I am unsure as to whether I will re-read again I know if I buy something in e format and love it I will also end up buying it in paperback when/if it is available.  So it's not really gonna save me any money.  I also fear not being able to find something when I want it.  I've downloaded a reader program to help with my ebook files and also plan on backing up on disk/sd card, but still, the fear remains.

 

 

You're right, Janet.  It

You're right, Janet.  It might be pretty embarrassing to be seen holding some of the covers of the books.  They're great though, you have to admit.  Some of 'em make even me blush! Innocent  Knowing my luck, I'd end up sitting next to a minister on the plane holding my Nocturne or Desire.  Now that could be sticky!  LOL!

Sheandan, you crack me up about the leather cover - the proverbial wolf in sheep's clothing, huh?  That's way too funny!

You always make such good points, Penn.  And, boy, are you organized with your layout, too.  I like the way you sum things up. Smile

"Kindness is the language which the deaf can hear and the blind can see."

- Mark Twain

Syndicate content