Do you ever pick a book or stay away from a book because of its setting?

Last night at my romance book club one member said she shied away from books set in areas she knows.  Someone else chimed in that she was worried that they would get the area wrong. 

It got me thinking about my book search by Australian authors while I've been here for the year.  I've loved finding books set in Victoria - Melbourne in particular like Ally Blake's book - Millionaire to the Rescue.  Would I looked for books in set in Australia before our stay here?  Not on my radar.  

I loved the two books by Kristan Higgins  (books read in January) because she talked about two of my favorite vacation spots - Cape Cod and Maine.  Fools Rush In had me thinking about Cape Cod.  She definitely got it right, down to our favorite place to purchase lunch from Lunch Box.  I smiled as the heroine was running on a road up towards the beach. I knew exactly where she was running. 

If you are reading a book and you know the setting, does it pull you out of the story if the author gets it wrong?  Do you mind when the author takes creative license and changes things to fit the story?  Tara Janzen's Crazy series comes to mind where she has in the notes at the front of the that she created the area where the headquarters are located.  Don't try to troll Denver to find it.

So.. shy away or look for those books written in locales that you know?  

Any books jump out that you read because of its setting?  Books you remember because the author got it wrong? 

~ Ann M. ~
~ The Forster's Fantastic Readers ~

Hi Ann!

I tend to stick to books set in the US, athough I read others (Cathy Mann's Wingmen Warriors come to mind -- I read those WHEREVER they're set!!). I'm not sure why, but I think it's because I'm more familiar with the lingo. Some books that use a lot of local phrases lose me when I can't figure out what they're talking about. I'm looking for escape, not an idiom lesson. 

But that's just me!

JodieG
Prepublished and workin' to change that!

A winner of the Big Finish 2 Contest, March 2008!

re: choosing/avoiding books because of settings

This is a really interesting topic. 

I love books set in places I know and quite often seek them out--maybe this is because the details are rarely that incorrect, since only people who actually live in Canada would likely write about Canada, whereas authors will often write about more romantic locales (Paris, Rome, etc.) without having lived there.  I love books set in Toronto or Ottawa or especially Ontario cottage country.

Also, I enjoy idioms when I'm in the mood and really like reading books by British authors...the slang is fun!  I remember as a kid reading a Tanith Lee book and being so confused by the talk of biros (pens) and one woman "hoovering" in the living room (I thought "hover" was misspelled and she was flying!  But it actually means vacuuming.)  

So it's funny that I have the opposite reactions to Ann's friend and Jodie!

Other book settings I seek out are those set near lakes, in the woods, or somewhere up north with lots of snow...those are much more romantic locales to me than big metropolitan cities.  

I avoid a few settings simply because I'm sick of them.  New York, for example--everything just tends to get a bit too "wow the city is wonderful rah rah go New York!" for me, and New Orleans is similar.  Sometimes I also get sick of European locales that get written about too frequently...Paris and anywhere in Italy, for example.  

If it's an author I like or the book sounds interesting, I'll still read it, but the setting does weight into my decision a bit.   

I do prefer books written

I do prefer books written about locales in North America.  I especially like books written about places where I've wanted to live (though I haven't actually been to any of them... Alaska, Washington, Oregon, and Maine).  And since I've been participating in the blogs (Jan. '07), I've enjoyed reading books set in Canada bc I've run across so many people on here who live there.  I think the books make those locales more real for me. 

I'm less likely to pick up books set in Melbourne, Australia or New Zealand.  (Books set in Brisbane are great bc I lived there, and books set in Sydney are okay bc I've visited, etc.).  I can't make much sense of it.  Maybe its some form of jealousy that I never managed to get there (too expensive).  I also seem to avoid books set in the South (of the US) - Alabama, Mississippi, Georgia, etc.

Jo

i dont really care about location....

i dont really dont care about location.   I like books set in other places so I can see how people live and talk in other places.  Weather it is another state, or another country.

But I wonder sometimes if the author has been to the location she is writing about.

When I see movies  or read books that are set in Los Angeles, sometimes I wonder if the person has ever been here.   Characters and setting sometimes seem so stereotyped.

Most movies set in LA are about "Boys in the Hood" (drugs, gansters, violence), or we are all blonde and beautiful "Bay Watch Babes".

Or if I watch a movie that referrs to LA, it has to do to those things.  Watching the movie "In Bruges",  Ralph Finnes character is buying an illegal gun, and is offerd an Uzzi.  and he says something like "an Uzzi?  I am not in South Central freaking Los Angeles".  And this guy is 6,000 miles away from  :"freakin Los Angeles" which he pronounces "Los Angeleeze".

On the series Numb3rs, they call locations I recognize, by different names.  But last nights episode actually did go to MacArthur Park.

Anyway, I think befor an author writes about a particular place-especially when the location is a character in the movie, book, whever- they should actually spend some time there. Hopefully staying with alocal so they can see how the people actually live, how they walk, talk, etc.

Terri
Got Books?

Most definately.  Until I started reading the reviews here about the books blokes and lassies "enjoyed" about Texas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, etc., I shyed away from books set in those locales.  I do like books set in UK countries since I am originally from Ireland and I "get" the language or meaning when other mates don't seem to, and I can relate to the scenes.  BUT ALSO, part of the joy of reading is that it takes one to far-off unfamiliar places s/he has never been before, and "allows" the reader to beome part of that landscape when s/he would never have been if it wasn't for the book.

"I went to a FIGHT the other night...and a HOCKEY GAME broke out!! "
HockeyDET@comcast.net

I'm all for an interesting

I'm all for an interesting setting. I love Australia, so I'm happy about all the books set there. I wish there were more European settings and why aren't there any set in Asia and South America? With a vivid setting you get to travel for the price of a book. It is perfect!

Oh! I forgot Ireland! I love

Oh! I forgot Ireland! I love reading books set in Ireland.

Jo

Hmmm, good questions. I do

Hmmm, good questions. I do tend to get on reading kicks around a locale if I discover something new about it through a book. Right now, I'm into the mediterranean region.

I don't stay away from books that are written in a locale that I know, though. I figure that everyone's experience colours how they define the place and that sometimes gives me a new way to see an area that I thought of in just one way. 

Murder Mysteries Set In NYC

I used to read any, and I mean any murder mystery, thriller, suspense novel, or crime fiction novel set in NYC.

I live in Brooklyn (one of five boroughs in NYC) and I enjoyed seeing if the author knew his/her stuff re: the Big Apple, sometimes called Gotham. 

I read a lot of lousy books that way and eventually gave up on using the NYC setting as a criteria.

But I enjoyed it while it lasted.

I love reading books set in

I love reading books set in places I know or places where I have lived.  Sometimes I actually buy a book because of the setting. 

AKA Merri
Family Challenge Team: The Spine Breakers with my dh Glenn AKA Phaedrus

Syndicate content