Okay. Something I never dreamed of, happened. I've been turned off by the 'feel' of a book. Call me shallow.
A couple of years ago, I tripped upon Elmore Leanord's blog. I admire the man and his writing. I was thrilled to find a top ten list of Leonard's 10 Rules of Writing. Many of his rules resonated with me. I blogged about it.
Then last year, I tripped upon the news that a book would be published based on those rules: Elmore Leonard's 10 Rules of Writing. Glory be! I revisted his blog and couldn't find the original post. Understood. The material was now a basis for a book.
Life and deadlines got in the way and it wasn't until today that I could check Leonard's 10 Rules of Writing out of the library. I opened the book anticipating, craving his wisdom. But alas. It was hard to turn the pages. Hard, stiff, cardboard like pages. Each with only a paragraph of copy or an illustration. The pages were hard to turn, the book hard to maipulate. I disliked the look, the feel. Ten rules that had been so important to me were lost in a gimmacky sales ploy. Not blaming Mr. Leonard. But man, I have never been so let down by the feel and look of a book.
Am I crazy? Has something similar ever happened to you? Have you ever been turned off by the look or feel of a book?
Talk to me! (Lest I think I'm a whack-a-doodle)
www.bethciotta.com
"...enchanting, madcap romance..." Publisher Weekly
"...wry humor; sexy, multifaceted characters..." Booklist







RE: A SHALLOW READER
I think that one of the things you AREN'T is a shallow reader. I am beginning to see that authors of Harlequins and Imprints need to be pretty tough cookies and adept at what they do. While the goal of the publisher is to sell books (I don't think any of us can argue with that) -- the "reading experience" is also sold: The joy, pleasantness, 'good-feelings', warm-fuzzies, etc., one gets when s/he reads a book. Too often, "back blurbs" that have little to do with the story, misleading wireless-interviews, cover art completely off-base (but sensational) is used to sell books. In the short run, the publisher may find this increases sales, but what about "real" readers? What about the faithful men & women that can read and use their God-given imaginations to create the scenes in their minds? What about the folks that actually grasp WORDS (as opposed to cover art of scantily-clad women & men), and by word-of-mouth can intelligently discuss what they've read? You are not being "Whack-a-Doodle" ~ but rather should be commended for bring up a good -- but touchy -- subject!
"I went to a FIGHT the other night...and a HOCKEY GAME broke out!! "
HockeyDET@comcast.net
Good to know
I won't need to check out that book. I love his rules. Too bad they've been reduced to...that.
I guess the only time a "feel" of a book bothers me is when the font is too small or the pages fall out on the first read. I HATE that.
Mary Beth
mbl's blog
http://marybethlee.livejournal.com
maybe tell the publisher...
i don't think that makes you a shallow reader at all. we read for pleasure and if it's not a pleasurable experience...then why do it? i could see myself feeling the same way. i might even consider writing to the publisher and telling them my qualms.
on the other hand, i have definitely read books just because they were brand new and i loved the crisp pages and the smell of the binding brought me back to all those "first days of school" when the future was unknown, but anticipated to be exciting.
Marty said...
<<While the goal of the publisher is to sell books (I don't think any of us can argue with that) -- the "reading experience" is also sold: The joy, pleasantness, 'good-feelings', warm-fuzzies, etc., one gets when s/he reads a book. >>
Amen to that! You said so many wonderful things in your post, Marty, I wasn't sure what to comment on. But your description of the 'reading experience' particularly resonated with me. You summed it up beautifully. Probably why I prefer a print book as opposed to an e-book. Because I want to hold that story in my hand. I want to turn the pages, feel the paper. All part of the experience.
Anyway, I honestly can't top your post. Thank you for sharing. Oh, and for saying I'm not a whack-a-doodle.
www.bethciotta.com
"...enchanting, madcap romance..." Publisher Weekly
"...wry humor; sexy, multifaceted characters..." Booklist
Mary Beth
I feel bad now. I don't want to turn you off from checking out the book. Maybe the 'feel' of the pages won't bug you.
In addition to a more comfortable feel, I guess I just wanted more text. There are ten rules. Ten short rules. The book is 89 pages long! Yet each page features only one paragraph or one line! Or an illustration. I was hoping for a 'how to' book when really it's a coffee table book. Aw, well. The rules are still great.
www.bethciotta.com
"...enchanting, madcap romance..." Publisher Weekly
"...wry humor; sexy, multifaceted characters..." Booklist
< What a great memory,
<
What a great memory, Theresa!
And now that you mentioned binding, if I cracked this one more, maybe those stiff, cardboard pages would be easier to turn. But it's the library's copy so I'll leave as is. Ah, well. :)
www.bethciotta.com
"...enchanting, madcap romance..." Publisher Weekly
"...wry humor; sexy, multifaceted characters..." Booklist
Beth, you are not a whack-a-doodle
The feel of a book is important! And yes, Marty, you really did a great job of summarizing the reading experience. The books that resonate on an emotional level are the books we love, so why not love a book based on the feel? If you are a whack-a-doodle, than sign me up. Physical feel of a book is just as important as the emotional impact.
Nancy
sheandeen@gmail.com
I don't like sales ploy
I don't like sales ploy books. So many guides nowadays are more gimmick. Presentation is important. I hate books that fall apart when you read them because i keep books, good reads anyhow. I don't like Hardcovers like paperbacks because the corners poke, always when I relax and am just really sinking into a book. Last night I wanted to read a certain book but changed my mind just because I did not feel like readingand holdingup a heavy trade paperback last night.
AKA Merri
Family Challenge Team: The Spine Breakers with my dh Glenn AKA Phaedrus